PREAMBLE
The Government of the United States and the Government of the
Marshall Islands:
In recognition of the enduring friendship between the
United States of America and the Republic of the Marshall Islands;
In reaffirmation of the compact of Free Association (the
Compact) between the Government of the United States and the Government
of the Marshall Islands;
In fulfillment of the provisions of Section 177 of the
Compact relating to the nuclear testing program which the Government
of the United States conducted in the Northern Marshall Islands
between June 30, 1946, and August 18, 1958 (the Nuclear Testing
Program);
In recognition of the authority and responsibility of
the Government of the Marshall Islands to provide medical and
health care to all of the people of the Marshall Islands; and
the expressed desire of the Government of the Marshall Islands
to include in its integrated, comprehensive and universal medical
health-care system, the health-care and surveillance programs
and radiological monitoring activities contemplated in United
States Public Law 95-134 and United States Public Law 96-205;
In recognition of the authority and responsibility of
the Government of the Marshall Islands to provide for the welfare
of all the people of the Marshall Islands; and the expressed desire
of the Government of the Marshall Islands to create and maintain,
in perpetuity, a means to address past, present and future consequences
of the Nuclear Testing Program, including the resolution of resultant
claims; and
In recognition of contributions and sacrifices made by
the people of the Marshall Islands in regard to the Nuclear Testing
Program;
NOW THEREFORE AGREE:
Article I
The Fund
Section 1 - Creation
In fulfillment of its obligations under Section 177 of the Compact,
the Government of the United States shall provide to the Government
of the Marshall Islands, on the effective date of this Agreement,
the sum of $150 million to create a fund (the Fund).
Section 2 - Management
In furtherance of the desire of the Government of the Marshall
Islands to provide, in perpetuity, a means to address past, present
and future consequences of the Nuclear Testing Program:
(a) The Government of the Marshall Islands shall cause the Fund
to be invested with the performance goal of producing for each
year of the existence of the Fund average annual proceeds of at
least $18 million (Annual Proceeds) for disbursement in accordance
with this Agreement.
(b) The Government of the Marshall Islands, in order to achieve
the performance goal of the Fund, shall retain as trustee and
manager of the Fund (Fund Manager) an United States investment
management company which has demonstrated substantial experience
in the administration of trusts and which has funds under management
in excess of $1 billion. The Fund Manager shall make disbursements
in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement to the designated
recipients in the name of "The Republic of the Marshall Islands
Nuclear Claims Fund".
(c) The Fund shall be invested in bonds, notes and other instruments
of investment grade and of United States nationality, including
both debt and equity issues, common or preferred stocks, money
market funds, certificates of indebtedness and mutual funds. The
Government of the United States shall impose no transaction fee
or intermediary charge on the investment of the Fund in instruments
of the Government of the United States.
(d) Except as may be otherwise required by this Agreement and
to achieve its desire to provide a perpetual means of addressing
the special needs and unique circumstances of the people of the
Marshall Islands resulting from the Nuclear Testing Program ,
the Government of the Marshall Islands shall not permit nor shall
the Fund Manager make disbursements from the Fund.
(e) For purposes of taxation only, the trust into which the Fund
is placed pursuant to this Article shall be deemed to be a charitable
trust under the laws of the United States and the Republic of
the Marshall Islands.
Article II
Distribution of Annual Proceeds
The Fund Manager shall disburse Annual Proceeds in accordance
with Article III of this Agreement and as follows:
Section 1 - Health, Food, Agricultural Maintenance and Radiological
Surveillance
(a) $30 million to the Government of the Marshall Islands, to
be disbursed in annual amounts of $2 million for the l5-year period
commencing one calendar quarter after the effective date of this
Agreement. The Government of the Marshall Islands shall use these
sums to obtain technical assistance, on a reimbursable basis,
from the United States Public Health Service and other agencies
of the Government of the United States. The Government of the
United States shall provide such technical assistance including
United States contractor services to assist the Government of
the Marshall Islands to include, in its health-care system, health-care
programs and services related to consequences of the Nuclear Testing
Program and contemplated in United States Public Law 95-134 and
United States Public Law 96-205. Such technical assistance shall
be obtained in accordance with Section 226 of the Compact, the
provisions of the Federal Programs and Services Agreement and
such separate implementing agreements as may from time to time
be concluded. Such technical assistance shall, at the request
of the Government of the Marshall Islands, include a whole body
counter and the training of its operator. The whole body counter
shall be located in a suitable facility chosen and supplied by
the Government of the Marshall Islands. The Technical assistance
provided for in this subsection may include professional personnel
services and dosimetry and bioassay services.
(b) Annual disbursements specified in this Section are in addition
to the funds referred to in Section 211 (a) (3), 216 (a) (2) and
211 (b) of the Compact, which may also be expended by the Government
of the Marshall Islands to provide its citizens with health-care
programs and services elated (sic) to consequences
of the Nuclear Testing Program.
(c) The Government of the Marshall Islands may dedicate any part
of the annual disbursements specified in this Section to the financing,
including matching financing, of other related health-care and
research programs and services of the Government of the United
States which are otherwise available to the Government of the
Marshall Islands.
(d) At the request of the Government of the Marshall Islands,
the Government of the United States shall provide technical assistance,
programs and services, on a reimbursable basis, to continue the
planting and agriculture maintenance program on Enewetak and to
continue the food programs of the Bikini people and Enewetak people
for as long as such technical assistance, programs and services
may be required. Such technical assistance, programs and services
shall be obtained in accordance with Section 226 of the Compact,
the provisions of the Federal Programs and Services Agreement
and such separate implementing agreements as may from time to
time be concluded.
(e) $3 million to the Government of the Marshall Islands for the
purpose of the conducting medical surveillance and radiological
monitoring activities, to be disbursed in average annual amounts
of $l million for the three-year period commencing on the effective
date of this Agreement. The results of such medical surveillance
and radiological monitoring activities shall be filed with the
Claims Tribunal referred to in Article IV of this Agreement.
Section 2 - People of Bikini
$75 million to the Bikini Distribution Authority referred
to in Article III of this Agreement, in payment of claims arising
out of the Nuclear Testing Program for loss or damage to property
and person of the people of Bikini to be disbursed in quarterly
amounts of $l.25 million for the 15-year period commencing one
calendar quarter after the effective date of this Agreement, and
which shall be distributed, placed in trust or otherwise invested
as the Bikini Distribution Authority may determine consistent
with this Agreement.
Section 3 - People of Enewetak
$48.75 million to the Enewetak Distribution Authority referred
to in Article III of this Agreement, in payment of claims arising
out of the Nuclear Testing Program for loss or damage to property
and person of the people of Enewetak, to be disbursed in quarterly
amounts of $8l2,500 for the 15-year period commencing one calendar
quarter after the effective date of this Agreement, and which
shall be distributed, placed in trust or otherwise invested as
the Enewetak Distribution Authority may determine consistent with
this Agreement.
Section 4 - People of Rongelap
$37.5 million to the Rongelap Distribution Authority referred
to in Article III of this Agreement, in payment of claims arising
out of the Nuclear Testing Program for loss or damage to property
and person of the people of Rongelap, to be disbursed in quarterly
amounts of $625,000 for the l5-year period commencing one calendar
quarter after the effective date of this Agreement, and which
shall be distributed, placed in trust or otherwise invested as
the Rongelap Distribution Authority may determine consistent with
this Agreement.
Section 5 - People of Utrik
$22.5 million to the Utrik Distribution Authority referred to
in Article III of this Agreement, in payment of claims arising
out of the Nuclear Testing Program for loss or damage to property
and person of the people of Utrik, to be disbursed in quarterly
amounts of $375,000 for the l5-year period commencing one calendar
quarter after the effective date of this Agreement, and which
shall be distributed, placed in trust or otherwise invested as
the Utrik Distribution Authority may determine consistent with
this Agreement.
Section 6 - Claims Adjudication Funds
(a) $500,000 to the Government of the Marshall Islands to provide
for the establishment of the Claims Tribunal, to be disbursed
prior to the first anniversary of the effective date of this Agreement.
(b) $500,000 annually to the Claims Tribunal during the term of
its existence for its operation, to be disbursed in quarterly
amounts of $125,000 commencing one calendar quarter after the
first anniversary of the effective date of this Agreement.
(c) $45.75 million to be made available to the Claims Tribunal
as necessary for whole or partial payment of monetary awards made
by the Claims Tribunal pursuant to Article IV of this Agreement,
to be disbursed in annual amounts of up to $2.25 million for the
3-year period commencing on the effective date of this Agreement,
and in annual amounts of up to $3.25 million for the 12-year period
commencing on the third anniversary of the effective date of this
Agreement.
Section 7 - Other Disbursements
(a) In the event that Annual Proceeds are not sufficient to meet
the disbursement schedules set forth in Sections 1 through 6 of
this Article, disbursements shall be made from the Fund on an
annual basis to supplement Annual Proceeds in the amount of the
difference.
(b) All monetary awards made by the Claims Tribunal pursuant to
Article IV of this Agreement shall be paid on an annual pro-rata
basis from available funds until all such awards are paid in full.
If, in any year, the annual amount made available pursuant to
subsection 6 (c) of this Article is not exhausted, the amount
not required for that year shall remain in the Fund and shall
be made available for disbursement in payment of monetary awards
made by the Claims Tribunal in subsequent years.
(c) Commencing on the fifteenth anniversary of the effective date
of this Agreement, not less than 75 percent of Annual Proceeds
shall be available for disbursement in whole or partial payment
of monetary awards made by the Claims Tribunal.
(d) Any Annual Proceeds which are not required for the disbursements
set forth in Section 1 through 6 and subsection 7(b) and 7(c)
of this Article shall either be made a part of the Fund or be
used by the Government of the Marshall Islands for other programs
and services for the people of the Marshall Islands as their unique
needs and circumstances resulting from the Nuclear Testing Program
may require, including continuation of the technical assistance
referred to in Section 1 of this Article, the operation of the
Claims Tribunal, the survey and analysis of the radiological status
of the Marshall Islands, and distributions to local government
councils so that they may establish and maintain programs and
services for their people as their unique needs and circumstances
resulting from the Nuclear Testing Program may require.
Section 8 - Bikini, Enewetak, Rongelap and Utrik Trusts
In order to provide an additional long-term means to address consequences
of the Nuclear Testing Program, the people of Bikini, Enewetak,
Rongelap and Utrik shall each for their own benefit provide for
the establishment of a trust funded with all or a portion of the
Annual Proceeds they shall receive under this Agreement. Each
trust shall be designed to provide a perpetual source of income
for its respective recipients, and shall be developed in consultation
with the Government of the Marshall Islands. The understandings
reached shall, in consultation with the Government of the United
States, be appended to this Agreement as Agreed Minutes. The establishment
of each trust in accordance with the applicable Agreed Minute
is a condition to disbursement of Annual Proceeds by the Fund
Manager to the respective distribution authorities.
Article III
Distribution Authority
Section 1 - Designated Distribution Authorities
The local government council for Bikini/Kili, Enewetak/Ujelang,
Rongelap and Utrik shall be the distribution authority for the
people of Bikini, Enewetak, Rongelap and Utrik, respectively.
Each distribution authority shall, as set forth in this Agreement,
receive and distribute, invest, or otherwise expend Annual Proceeds.
Section 2 - Additional Distribution Authorities
The Claims Tribunal may, from time to time, establish additional
distribution authorities as it deems appropriate and necessary
to carry out the intent of this Agreement.
Section 3 - Disbursements and Recordation
(a) Distribution, investment and other expenditure of Annual Proceeds
by a distribution authority shall be made in accordance with customary
law and traditional practice of the Marshall Islands, the Constitution
of the Republic of the Marshall Islands, and this Agreement.
(b) A distribution authority may assign its right to receive sums
provided under this Agreement, provided that the assignment is
consistent with this Agreement and provided that the distribution
authority indemnifies and holds harmless the Fund Manager, the
Government of the Marshall Islands and the Government of the United
States for any claims arising from the assignment.
(c) Each distribution authority shall, for purposes of notification
to the public and all interested parties regarding its determination
and actions, deposit with the Claims Tribunal an accounting of
its annual disbursements, within 120 days after the end of each
Marshall Islands fiscal year. Such accounting shall include a
list of the names of all individuals receiving payments and the
amounts received, and state the amounts disbursed for every other
purpose.
Article IV
Claims Adjudication Process
In furtherance of the desire of the Government of the Marshall
Islands to provide an additional long-term means for compensating
claims resulting from the Nuclear Testing Program:
Section 1 - Establishment and Operation of the Claims Tribunal
(a) The Government of the Marshall Islands, prior to the first
anniversary of the effective date of this Agreement, shall establish
a Claims Tribunal, in accordance with its constitutional processes
and this Agreement. The Claims Tribunal shall have jurisdiction
to render final determination upon all claims past, present and
future, of the Government, citizens and nationals of the Marshall
Islands which are based on, arise out of, or are in any way related
to the Nuclear Testing Program, and disputes arising from distributions
under Article II and III of this Agreement. This section confers
in the Claims Tribunal no jurisdiction over the United States,
its agents, employees, contractors, citizens or nationals with
respect to claims of the Government, citizens or nationals of
the Marshall Islands arising out of the Nuclear Testing Program.
(b) In the exercise of its jurisdiction, the Claims Tribunal shall
be independent of the legislative and executive powers of the
Government of the Marshall Islands.
(c) The Claims Tribunal shall have power to issue writs and other
processes, make rules and orders and promulgate other procedural
regulations, not inconsistent with the laws of the Marshall Islands
and this Agreement, as may be required. Such power shall include
the authority to make orders for the attendance of witnesses with
or without documents, and to make orders for the disposal of exhibits.
(d) Members of the Claims Tribunal shall be persons qualified
by education, experience and character to discharge judicial office,
shall hold office during good behavior for a set term of at least
three years, and shall be appointed pursuant to procedures adopted
by the Government of the Marshall Islands in accordance with its
constitutional processes.
(e) A member of the Claims Tribunal may be removed from office
only pursuant to procedures adopted by the Government of the Marshall
Islands in accordance with its constitutional processes and only
on the ground of clear failure or inability faithfully to discharge
the duties of such office or for the commission of treason, bribery,
or other high crimes or abuses inconsistent with the authority
of his office.
(f) No member of the Claims Tribunal shall take part in the decision
of a claim as to which he has a conflict of interest or the appearance
of a conflict of interest.
(g) The compensation of a Claims Tribunal member shall not be
changed during his term of office.
Section 2 - Awards and Costs of the Claims Adjudication Process
In making any award, the Claims Tribunal shall take into account
the validity of the claim, any prior compensation made as a result
of such claim and such other factors as it may deem appropriate.
Costs of proceedings before the Claims Tribunal shall be a charge
on Annual Proceeds, subject to determination of the Claims Tribunal,
the laws of the Marshall Islands and distributions made under
Sections 1 through 6 of Article II of this Agreement. Such costs
shall also include the cost of defending the Fund.
Section 3 - Governing Law
In determining any legal issue, the Claims Tribunal may have
reference to the laws of the Marshall Islands, including traditional
law, to international law and, in the absence of domestic or international
law, to the laws of the United States.
Article V
Tax Provisions
Section 1 - Exemption from United States Taxation
The sums provided for in Articles I and II of this Agreement,
and any earnings derived therefrom, shall not be subject to any
form of taxation by the United States or its political subdivisions
to the extent that those sums and any earnings derived therefrom
remain intact in an institution in the United States. Distribution
of those sums and any earnings derived therefrom to individuals
or other entities shall not be a transaction taxable by the Government
of the United States, but, after distribution, the earnings of
such distributed funds shall not be entitled to the tax exemption
provided in this Section.
Section 2 - Exemption from Marshall Islands Taxation
The sums provided for in Articles I and II of this Agreement and
any distribution of those sums shall not be subject to taxation
by the Government of the Marshall Islands, but, after distribution
to individuals or other entities, the earnings of such distributed
funds shall not be entitled to the tax exemption provided in this
Section.
Section 3 - Other Exemptions
The exemptions provided pursuant to Sections 1 and 2 of this Article
are without prejudice to any exemptions otherwise applicable.
Article VI
Resettlement of Bikini Atoll and Conveyance of Property
in respect to Bikini Atoll and Enewetak Atoll
Section 1 - Resettlement
The Government of the United States reaffirms its commitment to
provide funds for the resettlement of Bikini Atoll by the people
of Bikini at a time which cannot now be determined.
Section 2 - Bikini Sunken Vessels and Cable
Pursuant to Section 234 of the Compact, any rights, title and
interest the Government of the United States may have to sunken
vessels and cable situated in the Bikini lagoon as of the effective
date of this Agreement is transferred to the Government of the
Marshall Islands without reimbursement or transfer of funds. It
is understood that unexpended ordnance and oil remains within
the hulls of such sunken vessels, and that salvage or any other
use of these vessels could be hazardous. By acceptance of such
right, title and interest, the Government of the Marshall Islands
shall hold harmless the Government of the United States from loss,
damage and liability associated with such vessels, ordnance, oil
and cable, including any loss, damage and liability that may result
from salvage operations or other activity that the Government
of the Marshall Islands or the people of Bikini take or cause
to be taken concerning such vessels or cable. The Government of
the Marshall Islands shall transfer, in accordance with its constitutional
processes, title to such vessels and cable to the people of Bikini.
Section 3 - Enewetak Cable
Pursuant to Section 234 of the Compact, any right, title and interest
the Government of the United States may have to cable situated
in the Enewetak lagoon as of the effective date of this Agreement
shall vest in the Government of the Marshall Islands without reimbursement
or transfer of funds. By acceptance of such right, title and interest,
the Government of the Marshall Islands shall hold harmless the
Government of the United States from loss, damage and liability
associated with such cable and shall transfer, in accordance with
its constitutional process, title to such cable to the people
of Enewetak.
Article VII
Utilization of Lands
The Government of the United States is relieved of and has
no responsibility for, and the Government of the Marshall Islands,
consistent with its constitutional processes, shall have and exercise
responsibility for, controlling the utilization of areas in the
Marshall Islands affected by the Nuclear Testing Program. Assistance
to the Government of the Marshall Islands from the Government
of the United States in respect to the exercise of such responsibility
by the Government of the Marshall Islands is set forth in full
in this Agreement.
Article VIII
Northern Marshall Islands Radiological Survey
The Government of the United States has concluded that:
(a) The Northern Marshall Islands Radiological Survey and related
environmental studies conducted by the Government of the United
States represent the best effort of that Government accurately
to evaluate and describe radiological conditions in the Marshall
Islands; and
(b) The Northern Marshall Islands Radiological survey and related
environmental studies have been made available to the Government
of the Marshall Islands and can be used for the evaluation of
the food chain and environment and estimating radiation-related
health consequences of residing in the Northern Marshall Islands
after l978.
Article IX
Changed Circumstances
If loss or damage to property and person of the citizens of the
Marshall Islands, resulting from the Nuclear Testing Program,
arises or is discovered after the effective date of this Agreement,
and such injuries were not and could not reasonably have been
identified as of the effective date of this Agreement, and if
such injuries render the provisions of this Agreement manifestly
inadequate, the Government of the Marshall Islands may request
that the Government of the United States provide for such injuries
by submitting such a request to the Congress of the United States
for its consideration. It is understood that this Article does
not commit the Congress of the United States to authorize and
appropriate funds.
Article X
Espousal
Section 1 - Full Settlement of All Claims
This Agreement constitutes the full settlement of all claims,
past, present and future, of the Government, citizens and nationals
of the Marshall Islands which are based upon, arise out of, or
are in any way related to the Nuclear Testing Program, and which
are against the United States, its agents, employees, contractors
and citizens and nationals, and of all claims for equitable or
any other relief in connection with such claims including any
of those claims which may be pending or which may be filed in
any court or other judicial or administrative forum, including
the courts of the Marshall Islands and the courts of the United
States and its political subdivisions.
Section 2 - Termination of Legal Proceedings
The Government of the Marshall Islands shall terminate any legal
proceedings in the courts of the Marshall Islands against the
United States, its agents, employees, contractors and citizens
and nationals, involving claims of the Government, citizens and
nationals of the Marshall Islands, arising out of the Nuclear
Testing Program and shall nullify all attachments or any judgments
attained relating to such proceedings.
Article XI
Indemnity
Subject to Article IX, and in consideration for the payment
of the amounts set forth in this Agreement, the Government of
the Marshall Islands, on behalf of itself and its citizens and
nationals, shall indemnify and hold harmless the United States,
its agents, employees, contractors and citizens and nationals,
from all claims set forth in Article X of this Agreement, and
all actions or proceedings which may hereafter be asserted or
brought by or on behalf of the Government of the Marshall Islands,
its citizens and nationals, in any court or other judicial forum
based on, arising out of or in any way related to the Nuclear
Testing Program. The amount of such indemnification shall not,
in the aggregate, exceed $l50 million, and the Government of the
Marshall Islands shall use or cause the Fund, or other sums available
to it, to be used as necessary to cover or satisfy the indemnification
set forth in this Article.
Article XII
United States Courts
All claims described in Articles X and XI of this Agreement shall
be terminated. No court of the United States shall have jurisdiction
to entertain such claims, and any such claims pending in the courts
of the United States shall be dismissed.
Article XIII
Administrative Provisions
Section 1 - Effective Date
This Agreement shall come into effect simultaneously with
the Compact in accordance with Section 177 of the Compact.
Section 2 - Implementation
The Government of the Marshall Islands shall take all necessary
steps, of a general or particular character, to ensure the conformity
of its laws, regulations and administrative procedures with the
provisions of this Agreement and the implementation of this Agreement
in accordance with its terms.
Section 3 - Consultation
(a) The Government of the United States and the Government of
the Marshall Islands shall consult at the request of either of
them on matters relating to the provisions of this Agreement.
(b) The Government of the Marshall Islands may, from time to time,
request from the Government of the United States assistance of
an advisory nature with respect to the implementation of this
Agreement, including the investment of the Fund in instruments
of the Government of the United States and the establishment and
operation of the Claims Tribunal. Such advisory assistance shall
be provided in accordance with the provisions of Section 226 of
the Compact.
Section 4 - Amendment
This Agreement may be amended at any time by mutual consent
of the Government of the United States and the Government of the
Marshall Islands.
Section 5 - Duration
This Agreement shall remain in full force and effect until
terminated or otherwise amended by mutual consent.
Section 6 - Definitions
(a) The Definition of Terms set forth in Article VI of Title
Four of the Compact is incorporated in this Agreement.
(b) The term "citizens and nationals" of the Marshall
Islands or United States, as the case may be, includes:
(1) a natural person who is a citizen of the Marshall Islands
or the United States, and
(2) a corporation or other legal entity which is organized under
the laws of the Marshall Islands or the United States or any of
its states or territories, the District of Columbia or the Commonwealth
of Puerto Rico.